HabitRPG: Because doing the dishes sucks less when there’s treasure involved

1024_500

full_screen

The basic interface is clean, and serves as a nice compromise between traditional to-do lists and an RPG-style status screen.

In keeping with my general interest in gamification, I was floored when I found out about a web app called HabitRPG that promises to gamify your daily habits and reward you with various gimmicks (avatar upgrades, pets, etc). I’ve given it a try for a little over a week now and I think I’ve got enough insight to discuss some of my impressions.

In general, I think they’re onto something in a big way, and I believe that stroking the human reward circuitry with small but frequent rewards is the key to becoming the best people we can be. Several times in my wade through the site, I found myself wishing I had come up with the idea first. (On a side note, their project is open source, so the good news is that someone else could pick up the ball in the event that they gave up on it somewhere down the line).

For those of you who want an idea what the site’s all about, it’s based around the idea of listing out the habits you want to track – one-time to-dos, daily routines, and intermittent habits that you’d like to do more or less often, and then providing you with a system to reward and punish yourself. As the name implies, it’s inspired by role-playing game mechanics including health, (which depletes if you do a bad habit or miss a daily task) experience (which accumulates as you do good things and yields level increases that unlock site features), and gold (which you can use to unlock rewards like avatar equipment). It’s fairly intuitive once you understand the central mechanics, and the rewards make for a more interesting experience than you’d find in plainer to-do organizer.

customizations

If my program gave out pixel dudes, I’d have three PhDs by now.

In the time since I’ve started using it, I’ve already noticed more motivation to stay on top of my daily habits (I recently had an evening meeting that tempted me to skip a workout, a meditation session, and some guitar practice, but I forced myself to stick to all three when I got back lest I lose my streak.) What’s more, it’s given me motivation to take on tasks that I had largely ignored before. For example, I’m not the best at keeping on top of chores, but I find myself making a priority to hit a few simple ones as often as possible thanks to the looming promise of seeing a little pixelated version of myself in chain mail. Therefore, I can see how this could definitely help me use my time wisely and keep moving forward.

Here’s the breakdown of the pros and cons as I see them.

The Good:
– The interface is appealing, and the 8-bit style pixel art gives it a fun look and feel
– The existence of three types of tasks (Habits, Dailies, and To-dos) makes the game extremely versatile. Furthermore, the ability to switch off dailies on certain days makes good sense for recurring habits that shouldn’t happen 7 days a week. (Most sensible fitness enthusiasts give themselves some rest days, for instance)
– While it’s still under development, there has been some care taken to allow you to restore your character if the game crashes and robs you of a streak or an achievement. This is vital, since I’ve already needed to do that once and I can imagine the epic ragequit that would ensue if I’d already invested a lot of time and energy.
– The dual accountability systems of parties and guilds allows for some great opportunities to get support from friends and like-minded people. Granted it’s not much help if none of your friends are productivity geeks, but it’s nice to know that others will get to see your avatar dude clad in the coolest gear.
– Although I have not yet delved into it deeply, the creators are pursing integration with other programs pretty aggressively. This is wonderful for people who use a lot of gamified apps, organizers, and productivity tools. Ideally, it would be nice to go about my day as normal and have HabitRPG credit me for my web behavior (via the chrome extension), my to-dos (via Trello or similar), etc. This functionality seems to be in the works, but all the bugs aren’t yet worked out.
– The price is right. Without paying a dime, you get essentially full functionality with a couple of ads that don’t distract too much. I worry a bit that this could lead to some unsavory monetization tactics down the road, but I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt that they could monetize it without breaking the app for free members.
– The development pace appears brisk. The mobile app coming out soon has the potential to make it much easier to keep up on, and it seems like the authors have their ducks in a row, organizing their emerging features and bug fixes via a group Trello account that anyone can see.

The upcoming mobile app release will make it a lot easier to maintain your account.

The upcoming mobile app release will make it a lot easier to maintain your account.

The Bad:
– It’s slow and buggy in its current incarnation. If you’re expecting a fully polished product, it’s not quite there yet. (It is under active development, however, so I expect this complaint to be time-limited)
– The user-generated tasks and difficulties create somewhat of an apples to oranges environment. Obviously cheating will always be possible with apps like these, but here it’s totally possible for two honest players to have completely different levels and scores for doing the same things, all depending on how they’ve set up their lists and what they give themselves credit for. I think that it would be beneficial for there to be a library of democratically decided tasks to choose from, so you stand a better chance of being on the same page with your friends.
– The gem system worries me a little bit. It smacks of the special currencies in so many of the gimmicky facebook games, where there’s no access to certain perks without spending real money.

In closing, I think this is worth checking out, and is a viable alternative to other habit tracking sites like alive.do, lift, and so forth. It’s not yet my sole to-do manager, but I could definitely see it being a major hub to keep myself organized in the future. There’s a lot of potential in this concept, so I hope to see it turn into something even more addictive in a couple of years.

(In lieu of collecting links in the post, I’ve begun curating productivity sites in the sidebar, and I plan on continuing to add to it as I find more. I’m always open to suggestions if there’s something out there that you’d like me to check out or review.)

Minor update 12/10/13:

I’ve been using HabitRPG for months now, and the angularJS rewrite did in fact make it run considerably faster and crash a bit less. I will say that the game doesn’t seem to be designed very well for people who actually keep on top of their habits, as it’s quite easy to obtain the maximum armor in just a few months’ time, and there’s not really anything else to spend gold on. With this much usage, a few of their minor issues have begun to grate on me:

  • Development is ongoing, and features are being added with some regularity. However, the developers have a clear priority for making exclusive content for backers and contributors, and much of the other optional content is only available for purchase using gems. I understand that the developers need to make money to keep the site going, but I’d rather have them break down and charge money or use more obtrusive advertising instead of dividing the game into “haves” and “have nots” and spoiling their inner circle with perks. It doesn’t make sense to me that I should have to learn how to program and contribute to their project if I want to get all the achievements and upgrades.
  • Related to the above issue, my earlier fears about this gem system have been confirmed. Much like the free-to-play facebook games that award one currency freely but keep an unrelated currency in extremely short supply, I find myself drowning in gold while I have no way of getting gems without buying them outright with real money. This has seriously diminished my motivation to continue using the platform, and in fact I’m debating forking the code to see if I can work from a local install where I can buy gems and drops with gold so that I have some way to progress.
  • The fact that the game is constantly under development sort of ruins the current gold mechanic. There is talk of adding character classes at some point, so I’d rather hoard my gold and buy equipment for the other character types when it arrives rather than creating my own (out-of-game) rewards and losing the gold when I need it to improve the game.
  • The item drop system is arbitrarily capped at 2 per day (at least it was when I looked into it). Because I have several dailies with long streaks, this cap was usually maxed out fairly early in the day, meaning I didn’t get any particularly interesting rewards for everything else I was hoping to do that day. I’m not really sure why there needs to be a cap at all, but I found it ruined my motivation when I was checking boxes for nothing but a little bit of (currently useless) gold.
  • The item drop system really should consider what’s in your reserves before dropping an item, especially in light of the extremely limited cap. I’m sitting on over a dozen animal eggs at the moment and have never had a surplus of either food or hatching potions. I understand that this would take a little bit of extra programming, but the developers have to consider that most regular users are going to hit an “endgame” state pretty fast given the relative ease of maxing out the weapons and armor, and it’s lame to keep getting wolf eggs when I already have enough to hatch every wolf cub in the game.
  • Yet another complaint about the item drop system: It’s possible to sell eggs back to the stable, but only for gold. This is better than nothing, but it again does nothing for players who have bought all that there is to buy.
  • The challenges system has been implemented, and promises an in-game way to obtain gems, but so far I haven’t found any use for it. Usually, by the time I find a challenge that’s relevant to me, it’s already been going for a few days and it’s impossible for me to win. I don’t really have time to check every day to see if there are official challenges being launched for the stuff I’m already doing, but if I wanted to win gems in game I would have to do that and move from the daily version I’m already using to the one supplied in the challenge. In short, it’s a nice idea but it’s not really geared toward people who are already on top of things.

In conclusion, HabitRPG is still a great premise, but its gamification features start to fall apart after a few months of successful “gameplay.” Mostly, I feel like it’s badly in need of additional content to keep the core gameplay going. If they had hundreds of armor pieces to purchase, even if they were purely cosmetic, it would at least give players something to work for. I feel like there’s a wall in place, and the only people who are getting the full experience are those who have been friends of the project from the beginning. If you already contribute to the project regularly, backed the kickstarter, and feel comfortable paying money for gems, then you get to be a special class of player with diamond armor, unique pets, and achievements specific to contributors. For the rest of us, we’re relegated to a sort of proletarian status where we’ll have to be content with an arbitrary blockade in our progress because we serve our own goals rather than those of the habitRPG team. If I were in charge, I would do away with most of the special privileges and allow anyone to buy “habitRPG premium” for some annual fee, which would enable all of the in-game content to be buyable with gold.

About these ads

9 thoughts on “HabitRPG: Because doing the dishes sucks less when there’s treasure involved

    • Does seem that way :) Sounds like your PhD is serious business, though. I’m just wading through a sea of western blots, ELISAs, and immunohistochemistry slides, nothing quite so cutting edge.

      Reply
  1. Creator of Habit here. I’m all about Good/Bad/Uglies, and hope to be a good sport about them. Habit’s seen it’s fair share of Uglies, especially pre-August “Derby Days”. But I want to address some of the points here, since it seemed a bit like a FUD – especially the update.

    Firstly, everything in the game can be achieved without Gems except piddly character customizations (some hair colors, beards, shirt colors, etc). Everything that’s purchasable which counts towards game play (quests, bosses, mounts, pets) can be found as random drops; and the rest is free or gold-based (challenges, classes, gear, etc). We’re very careful not to exclude players from any gameplay, and instead Gems are used to speed up inconveniences or color your hair. So I’m not really sure where this argument is coming from.

    Regarding contributor rewards: we’re actually quite proud of this movement. Remembering that Habit is an Open Source project, not yet rackin’ it in (so far it’s been lunch-money tops for a handful of us) means that *all* of us working on it are doing so in our spare time, nights and weekends. The more hands helping out, the better for everyone. Before we added Contributor Gear, this was *my* project. If I got hit by a bus, y’all would be SOL – Habit’s dead. Since adding Contrib Gear, we’ve quadrupled the helping hands. Artists, developers, writers, designers, project managers – it’s now a thriving community, a self-sustaining project! The goal of incentivizing contribution is to create a community garden. Love the project? Want that next tier of gear? Pay it forward. In a community garden, you don’t call biggest helpers the “haves” and fly-by-nights the “have nots” – no, you thank the top helpers for keeping the garden alive! Really, adding Contributor Gear was one of the best moves for Habit’s history.

    Reply
  2. Hey Lefnire, I appreciate your maintaining a civil tone in light of what are admittedly some pretty harsh attacks on your program. I do think it’s worth me putting in one more update, probably in a new blog post altogether, because much of what’s above is out of date. For one, the original post was released in August, when most of my experience with the program was from the pre-angularJS build. The comments in the “minor update” come from a time in November before classes, mounts, and quests had been released, so I had been at a point where I could earn no more gear through normal means (I had had the golden stuff for a while), and the pet drops were frustrating because I had several long streaks and yet only got two drops a day. This put me in the situation where I had basically exhausted all the reward content in the game, which made it less enjoyable to use. Admittedly, the new content has multiplied the available content significantly, and my frustration about backer and contributor gear is somewhat less because of the abundance of content for the ‘common man.’

    While I don’t intent to erase the comments I made because I did feel that way at the time, I hope you’ll understand that I do think you have a good product on your hands, one that’s worth paying for and one that I’d like to see succeed. I do hope you’re familiar with the “pay to win” criticisms that are often leveled at free-to-play MMORPGs, and that some, myself included, may feel similarly about the current pay model for HabitRPG. Now, obviously you have plenty of satisfied users, and I’m still using the product myself, so you can certainly take my criticisms with a grain of salt. I will continue to advocate for a flat-rate pay option to make gems (or the gem-yoked rewards) somehow earnable in-game, but if I have to cobble together a similar system by simply buying a pack of gems once a month, I most likely will.

    Reply
    • Thanks Cody. And yeah, makes sense not to delete the original – it’s a paper trail of progress.

      FWIW, we’re looking into moving all unlockables to optional gold-purchasables. So instead of waiting till 10 for classes, you an pay GP. 11-14 for spells, you can pay GP. See http://goo.gl/SKoyGY for detail. We’re also going to move class-changing to GP, so you have 4x the gear to collect with GP. As far as new content to keep things fresh, that’s solved by the Quest system. It’s extremely easy for the community to add new quests and bosses (vid tut at http://goo.gl/u53IXU), and we’ll roll a new batch every ~2 weeks. Additionally, quests have an arc mechanic, so Habit can start having an official story-line through quests and bosses, which we’ll make sure to drag on forever and ever ;) We already have a huge backlog (they’re so easy to add), and we’re simply waiting for the Winter Event so users don’t get distracted all over the place.

      Now, your idea about a recurring premium plan to do away with Gems (convert them all to gold I presume?). I don’t think anyone’s suggested that before, and it’s very interesting. I’m scratching my chin right now and thinking seriously. If you haven’t already, chime in on Trello, ping @wc8 (she’s kinda our monetization philosopher) with your idea, and I’ll start brewin’

      Reply
      • I dropped a note on the Trello, although I apologize if it was in the wrong thread. The changes you’re proposing are all great, and I think there’s enough content to keep people playing longer now, which will probably keep people from hitting a wall by exhausting all of the content. I threw out some suggestions for the premiumification of the gem system. Converting gems to gold would work, as would allowing premium members to convert gold to gems at some rate, allowing premium players to get gems as drops and/or levelup rewards, etc. Basically, anything that allows me to support the project while still feeling like I’m unlocking rewards with my habits instead of my wallet would be incredible.

        I like the direction things are going. Now that there’s enough content to satisfy us smallfolk, it’s less of a sin in my eyes for contributors to get special stuff.

  3. Interesting discussion. I’m a new Habit’er, but my main question for the OP is: Have you no interest in custom rewards? That seems to be the most exciting part of HRPG to me. I have little interest in customizing my avatar or gaining XP, although I realize the upgrades will be useful/required (adding health, defense, etc) down the road. But in general, virtual rewards are in no way going to motivate me to actually work on my habits and goals. The custom rewards that I define myself (“Have a beer!”, etc) are much more enticing, and really encourage me to balance my work/play ratio.

    I mean, obviously HRPG is built around the idea of the RPG gameplay, so I can understand that you want those mechanics to be satisfying. But if you’re not utilizing custom rewards, I think you’re missing out on one of the big features and points of the game itself. It’s not JUST an RPG, nor is it JUST a task/goal/habit tracker. It’s a weird, awesome blend that you have to use BOTH ways to get the most effect.

    Like I said, I understand where you’re coming from, but I also kind of think you’re criticizing it while at the same time not really using it as intended. Just as you NEED the RPG character upgrades to thrive and succeed in HRPG, you NEED custom rewards to offer enduring value to the real-life aspect. You must admit that eventually there is some practical limit to the number of character upgrades or pre-canned rewards. For the system to continue to work, you need a self-sustaining reward mechanism – a carrot to dangle for yourself as it were.

    That’s what I love about HRPG — you can reward yourself however you see fit, with whatever works for you. It could be food, recreation, or actual monetary savings goals (i.e. – 500 GP = new Xbox game!). You can keep the system going indefinitely that way, and not rely on the limited in-game mechanics.

    Just my 0.02 GP :-)

    Reply
    • Hey Jesse, I’m going to be writing a somewhat updated post this month because of all the new content that’s been added, so some of my complaints in the update are now moot. In response to your comment specifically, I think it’s great that the option of providing custom rewards is there, but I guess it didn’t/doesn’t do it for me. Where I’m at in life, I don’t really have a lot of cash or time to spare for real world pursuits, so I find it much more motivating to spiff up my pixel dude. Now that there’s more than 4x as much content and the option to buy rebirths, this is less of an issue. I’m not knocking your approach though, in the least, and I do rather wish I could get into using it that way, but it just feels like I’m robbing my ‘game’ to pay for my real reward.

      Reply
  4. Pingback: HabitRPG Revisited: 6 months of Gamified Living | The Ten of Swords

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s